Monticello IN Real Estate & Homes for Sale

This private oasis is a self-sustained retreat with 3000 linear feet and ~160 acres of waterfront property on Lake Shafer near the quaint town of Monticello. This has everything you can possibly want or need with much, much more. There are 3 magnificent spacious and inviting homes that each sleep over 10, a state-of-the-art barn with a guest suite, an aerated fishing pond stocked with bass. A fishing hut with a full bath and kitchenette covered deck and sleeps 4. If that isn't enough you will find 2 boat houses with automatic lifts, one of which has a party room, kitchen, and powder room. Sandy beach, boat dock, sand volleyball court, fire pit, plumbed grills and decks with picnic benches, kids' jungle gym, outdoor basketball court, indoor basketball court, work out room, fenced grazing pastures, a private bayou, trails, forest, a creek, chicken coop, an orchard, farmland and tranquil open space. Too much to describe!

Make this exquisite river oasis dream property your reality! Completely updated inside and out in 2015, this Tippecanoe River home will offer you years of maintenance-free living so you can enjoy all the splendor and wonders of the river. Panoramic views of the river will delight you from the home's interior as well. A concrete boat ramp adds to the allure of this impeccably cared-for home on one of the best stretches of the river. The covered porch with gas fireplace make enjoying the river views even more enjoyable. A huge walk-in pantry, and wood burning stove round out the incredible kitchen. the 30X36 garage even comes complete with electricity.

If you love river life and are seeking rest and relaxation, this 3 bedroom, 1 bath home is just what you need. Access the nearly new wrap-a-round trex deck by climbing the stairs or use the elevator/lift. Walk a few steps out into your yard to dip your toes in the river while sitting on the concrete seawall or launch your boat, canoe or jet ski in the water at the community public easement or use the shared boat dock just a few steps away. Whatever relaxation looks to you, i am sure you can find it here. Schedule your tour today.

One story home on almost a full acre of land in the country, offering the perfect blend of tranquility and convenience. This 3 bedroom, 2 full bath has a spacious master bedroom en-suite with a walk-in closet and a large bathroom with both a tub and stand alone shower. There is plenty of room to enjoy the expansive yard and many possibilities for outdoor enjoyment. Although some updates could enhance the overall appeal of the home, its proximity to Indiana Beach, shopping and dining make it an ideal location for those seeking a peaceful retreat just minutes away from downtown Monticello.

Welcome to the Kingsley Estate! They say, "Home is where the heart is!" The Kingsley family created decades of fond family memories in this special gem of a home. It is a joy to watch many deer gather peacefully on the massive 4-acre waterside lot. Home-grown plants and vegetables enhanced fun meals and discussions with loved ones. The grandkids cherished the upstairs game room and always made a straight path to "their" hideout away from their parents, while Grandpa and Grandma just smiled with joy. You will love the craftsmanship of "THE" log cabin in Monticello. It is custom-designed, and no detail is overlooked. Master builders constructed the estate using logs from Montana and Wisconsin. Evening campfires overlooking the water made nighttime an event in itself. The Kingsley's only wish to pass along these special moments to a new generation of owners and realize much happiness awaits. Some things are priceless, and the Kingsley Estate is!

Looking for the perfect summer or weekend retreat? This adorable, charming, and meticulously maintained cottage with a beautiful view of Lake Freeman is the perfect get away!!! The 2 large decks lake side provide great space for outdoor entertaining and this home includes a boat slip! There is a bunkhouse with extra storage and bedroom space to use as a private master or for guests to have their own space! When entertaining there is plenty of parking at the nearby community grounds provided for overflow parking or boat trailer storage. There is also a common firepit and swimming area with deck all just a short walk away! The recently added mini-split heating and cooling system will keep the indoor temperature comfortable year round.

Welcome to the timeless elegance of this stunning 1905 Victorian home nestled in the heart of Monticello. This meticulously maintained residence offers an enchanting blend of period details and contemporary updates. Boasting 5 bedrooms, 3 full baths, and a partially finished attic perfect for a studio or game room, this home is sure to capture your imagination. Stepping from the charming covered spacious front porch, you are greeted by a grand foyer adorned with intricate woodwork, bench seating conversation area, and leaded and stained glass windows, thus setting the tone for the exquisite craftsmanship found throughout the home. The spacious living room features soaring ceilings, ornate trim and moldings, with plenty of room for entertaining and opens to the spacious formal dining room with built-in cabinetry with pass-through from the butler's pantry that offers plenty of additional storage cabinetry. The open kitchen has an abundance of windows and light boasts a full suite of stainless appliances, ample counter space and a small eat-up bar. The adjoining sunroom could also serve as your informal dining area. Also on the first floor is a beautiful bedroom at the front of the home with stunning pocket doors and could be used as a home office or additional living space. A 1/2 guest bath has an added custom tile shower area tucked under the staircase. Up the stunning wood staircase you'll find a comfy loft with all 4 bedrooms off of this landing. The 4 bedrooms offer flexibility with guests bedrooms, home offices or hobbies with an abundance of closet space and 2 full bathrooms with sunken jetted tub and separate shower in one bathroom for comfort and convenience for all. Ascend to the mostly-finished attic, where endless possibilities await. Whether you envision a serene studio space bathed in natural light or a lively game room for entertaining, this versatile area can be tailored to suit your lifestyle. In the basement, you'll find a large laundry room, oversized utility room for storage and a finished area for hobbies or home gym! Be amazed at the laundry chute from level 2 to the basement! An oversized, backyard with brick patio space, plenty of lawn to enjoy, garden areas, and a detached 2.5 car well-insulated garage with workshop space! Schedule your private showing today and experience the charm and sophistication of turn-of-the century living!

Updated lake house on Shafer! This adorable home offers a multilevel deck and boat lift to enjoy the lake all season long and a 4 seasons room for the rest of the year. This lake house boasts 2 spacious bedrooms, large updated kitchen and 1.5 bath, dining area and 2 living spaces. Get ready for lake season!

This quaint ranch home is nestled in amongst trees but close to Lake Freeman. The bathroom has been totally renovated. Entertain your friends and family in the large backyard. Roof was updated in 2015 and the furnace and central air unit was updated in the fall of 2022. Updates from 2023: Electrical panel & meter upgraded from 100 amp to 200 amp. New glass cooktop stove, dishwasher, and garbage disposal. New windows throughout with 20 year warranty on window parts and glass. Eavestroughs & leaf guards added to exterior. Enjoy being close to the water and hearing the birds chirp in the summer. This home also comes with an easement to get down into the water. Enjoy the lake life by making this cozy home on Colonial Oaks Dr. yours! Inspections welcome, being sold AS-IS.

A SPACIOUS PLACE REMODELED WITH TASTE! Relax and enjoy life in this handsomely remodeled home with secluded wooded views & nestled within a quiet Lake Freeman neighborhood. This 2000+ sq ft. 3 bed/2.5 bath beauty has been completely redone over the past few years, including (but not limited to) roof, siding, bath rooms, gutters, windows, doors, appliances, interior paint, new patio...just to name a few! (SEE LIST UNDER 'DOCUMENTS') And no shortcuts taken here; everything done with 'quality' in mind. Open main-level living space & a spacious living area above made better by the open loft design and the homes cathedral ceilings. If you're looking for space and appreciate good taste, then this is your place!

Beautiful waterfront home on Upper Lake Freeman with 70 foot of water frontage. This 2-story home has 3 bedrooms and 1 and half bathrooms including an apartment located above the attached garage. This apartment features 5 rooms with it's own washer and dryer. The home includes a gas fireplace located in one of the bedrooms upstairs, new water softener, and new vinyl plank flooring in the main living area. A portion of the house has been raised and the main house is located all on the 2nd Level. The addition was completed in 2019. This home also has a basement that is partially finished with a half bathroom. Book your showing today to see what additional features this home has to offer!

Discover lakeside luxury in this completely remodeled 3-bed, 2-bath, 1776 sq. ft. Lake Shafer Home. Enjoy 98 feet of frontage on over an acre of land stocked with a 32 x 24 pole barn. Revel in the upgraded kitchen, expanded bedrooms, and a new walk-in closet in the primary suite. Quartz countertops, new flooring, paint, light fixtures, appliances, windows, doors and trim create a fresh, modern feel. The main floor bathroom features a new tiled walk in shower and heated jet soaking tub. With a fully finished walkout basement, this lake home offers the perfect blend of comfort and style. Welcome to your lakeside retreat.

Prime Lake Property with Panoramic View of Main Lake Shafer!! Newly updated retaining wall with new steps to the lake. Beautiful 5 Bedroom, 3 Bath home with walk out basement and it not only sits on over an acre of land but also has 145 ft of main lake frontage across NW Shafer Drive. 2 beautiful kitchens both newly remodeled with white cabinets, stainless steel appliances and quartz countertops. This home was designed to entertain with an in-ground heated pool that over looks beautiful Lake Shafer. It has two fireplaces, hardwood floors, all newly remodeled bathrooms. An oversized 2 car attached garage along with plenty of room for storage. Bonus: This home has two meters and can be rented out for additional income or Mother -N- Law Suite. Lake/Country setting yet only 3 minutes to town.

YEAR-ROUND OR VACATION BOUND? Whatever your needs may be, this home offers an array of possibilities! Situated on 2 lots, this 3 bed-2 bath ranch home comes with an adjacent 3rd lot for any expansion or auxiliary buildings needs, plus a 4th lot with 95' of main Lake Shafer frontage to satisfy all of your waterfront recreational desires. Inside you can take in the lake views from the master bedroom, and both the living & family rooms. Original hardwood flooring potentially exists under the carpet in the guest bedrooms & the living room (the latter also features a fireplace and built-ins). "Good bones" abound here, along with a newer roof & central air unit. Laundry room, 2-car attached garage, plenty of closets & storage, PLUS interest in, & use of, the neighborhood common area directly behind house. Be it land or lake, this one has the best of both worlds! *INSPECTIONS WELCOME BUT PROPERTY IS BEING SOLD "AS IS"*

Lake Freeman Fixer Upper! This mobile home with an addition needs some TLC, but is an affordable way to have a waterfront property. Spend your weekends remodeling and then take some time off on the lake. Large storage area under the addition. Property being sold in as condition. Start the project now then enjoy the lake this summer!

DISCOVER LUXURY LIVING IN THIS REMODELED 3 STORY HOME WITH 5 BEDROOMS, 4 BATHS, WITH 2800 SQ.FT. WITH PLENTY OF SPACE FOR COMFORT. ENJOY THE SPACIOUS INTERIOR WITH OPEN CONCEPT, LIVING ROOM WITH GAS FIREPLACE, KITCHEN AND DINING ROOM WITH AMPLE CABINETS,AND ABUNDANCE OF WINDOWS PROVIDING VIEWS OF THE LAKE. THE THIRD FLOOR OFFERS A REC ROOM WITH A WET SINK AND BUILT IN BAR FOR ENTERTAINING. EXTERIOR BOAST A NICELY LANDSCAPE YARD, COVERED PORCH, 5O' LAKE LEVEL WATERFRONT, AND A 16 X 58 DETACHED GARAGE. YOUR DREAM HOME AWAITS!

Beautiful Lake property with 3 bedrooms, 3 baths, over 1 acre and only 4.6 miles from Indiana Beach and 2 hours from Chicago! This beautiful open concept property surrounded by trees has so much to offer: hardwood floors, quartz countertops, numerous parking space, a shed, 2 oversized decks, wheelchair ramp (the entire main level is wheelchair accessible with ramps, 34-inch-wide doors, grab bars in bathroom) an outside shower, NOT in a FLOOD ZONE, LOW TAXES to mention a few. The master bedroom includes a walk-in closet, tile bathroom and a private deck where you can enjoy the beautiful lake view. House was completely rebuilt in 2009 and got some updates since last sold. List of updates available. Schedule your private showing today!

Main Lake Freeman Brick Exterior 4/5 bed, 4 full bath custom home with lakeside Salt Water Pool 16x40 in-ground pool w/ automatic cover and poolside gazebo. 3 car garage with overhead door opening to poolside. 30x50 covered 2 bay boat dock with 2 PWC lifts and extra large fishing pier with composite decking, steel driven seawall. Excellent location in an upscale neighborhood south of Monticello with close commute to Lafayette/West Lafayette. High end features with this house include; Custom oak kitchen with 6x6 island, stainless appliances, Anderson Windows. Open floor plan with views of water from living areas, gas fireplace in dining area for Chilly evenings. 10x16 sunroom off dining area with hot tub, partially finished basement with entrances from living room and garage. Main Suite is located on ground floor with tiled bathroom. 13x17 oversized laundry room, central vacuum system. Chair lift to water, new wooden stairs also to water. Enjoy time in the pool while overlooking the wide portions of Main Lake Freeman and Ski Island.

Discover your perfect oasis in this spacious 3-bed, 3-bath brick ranch home nestled on a large lot in a tranquil, tucked-away neighborhood just 5 minutes from town. With new appliances, a generous dining room, a recently added additional bathroom conveniently located off the laundry room, a 2-car attached garage, and a 2.5-car detached garage with a workshop, this property has it all. Complete with a carport and a sizable building in the back, sitting on nearly 1.5 acres, it's been lovingly maintained and thoughtfully updated. Your dream home awaits!

Welcome to your charming lakeside retreat on the picturesque shores of Lake Freeman! This adorable cottage is as cute as a button and boasts stunning views of the tranquil waters that stretch as far as the eye can see. Step inside, and you'll find a cozy and inviting space that feels like home. The cottage comes fully furnished, and most items stay, making it practically turn-key for your convenience. Imagine yourself enjoying lazy mornings on the deck with a cup of coffee, soaking in the breathtaking scenery that surrounds you. One of the standout features of this property is the permanent boat lift with a protective metal roof, ensuring that your watercraft is not only secure but also shielded from the elements. Whether you're an avid boater or simply love the idea of having easy access to the water, this feature adds a touch of convenience to your lakeside lifestyle. Don't miss the opportunity to own this delightful Lake Freeman cottage. Embrace the serenity, charm, and the turn-key convenience of this lakeside gem. Your dream lakefront living experience awaits!

PRICE REDUCED!!! Nice home with 3 acres total. Private setting with partial fencing and Tree line. Country View and tillable land within 1/4 mile of Lake Shafer. 30x40 det. garage with storage loft, concrete flooring. Home has nice decks, 6x9 concrete storm shelter. Home has been well maintained and cared for with updates to plumbing, floor coverings, updated appliances. Nice wood burning fireplace for chilly evenings, skylight in main bathroom. Front of house has wood deck/ramp entry, backdoor has aluminum ramp entry. A nice split floor plan. One of the nicest country settings you will find close to Lakes. Asphalt County Road Access.

Embrace the PINNACLE of LAKESIDE Living with this exceptional property on Lake Shafer. Offering a magnificent view of the lake, this 2-unit residence can be expanded to a possible 4-unit haven. Immerse yourself in the outdoor oasis, featuring a pergola, an inviting inground pool, a new boat lift, a jumping deck, a thrilling lake slide, and a convenient jetski dock. With brick exteriors, both homes provide 4 beds, 2 baths, a single 2.5 car garage, additional parking, and gated access. Whether you desire a multifamily retreat or a smart investment opportunity, this unique property, sold as-is, promises an unparalleled experience and one of the most coveted lake views. Don't let this one-of-a-kind opportunity slip away!