Montauk NY Real Estate & Homes for Sale

Welcome to this classic Montauk home, where history meets opportunity! Nestled in the heart of this vibrant community lies a gem waiting to be polished! 21 S Elroy, an Original Carl Fisher Home - built by the individual who was responsible for creating the Montauk we all love and know today! This historic 3 Bedroom, 3 Full Bathroom includes 2 different Lofts with 2 Separate Stair Cases, a Full Basement, Detached 1 Car Garage, Vaulted Ceilings and Reclaimed Wood throughout the home! House needs TLC and Updating but has tremendous potential, take this once in a life time opportunity to own a piece of Montauk History!

Welcome to Montauk's Dome Home! Experience the epitome of architectural innovation and exclusivity with this one-of-a-kind dome home in Montauk. Situated on a secluded private road, this custom-built residence offers a rare opportunity to indulge in a lifestyle of tranquility and luxury all in one. The striking design boasts 360 views, allowing you to enjoy the beauty of Montauk from every direction. Inside, you'll discover a meticulously crafted interior featuring custom stone floor, huge windows and airy cathedral ceilings that will inspire new ways to relax, create and entertain. Complete with 3 spacious bedrooms and 2.5 bathrooms, this home is designed for comfort and convenience. Imagine waking up nestled in natural serene surroundings and starting your day with breathtaking views on the sun-splashed deck. Also from the third floor, you can catch a glimpse of Connecticut. Located close to the area's famous beaches, the Montauk Lighthouse and the village, you'll have easy access to everything Montauk has to offer. Whether you spend time dining at exquisite restaurants, surfing along the coast, or simply basking in the sun, the Dome puts you close to it all. In addition to the secluded location, this property offers low annual taxes, making it one of the wisest investments in the posh Hamptons area. The dome home in Montauk is not just about the property itself; it's about the exclusivity, privacy and possibilities that come with owning such a unique residence as your perfect nearby escape from New York. Watch tranquility take shape with this once-in-a-lifetime opportunity.

Beautiful home in coveted Culloden Shores Beach community with Bay Beach access. A rare five bedroom home with lots of space. Well maintained and ready for its next owners vision!

Amazing investment opportunity and OWN IN MONTAUK! Located across the road from the ocean is the Royal Atlantic North at 131 South Emerson Avenue, unit #238. This second-floor unit features a living/dining area with a slider out to a balcony overlooking the pool, galley kitchen, bedroom and bath. This complex is conveniently located across from the beach and right next to restaurants and shops. Call for an appointment to view. The rental income covers all costs and has been very profitable for owner for over 6 years.

This newly built modern barn style home in Montauk's Hither Hills offers a warm and inviting elegance, yet fresh and beachy feel. This custom new construction is situated on .70 acres offering the ever popular and desirable deeded ocean beach rights and also featuring four en suite bedrooms plus 2 additional bedrooms. The expansive layout boasts an impressive 6,700 +/- sq ft of living space spread throughout three levels. The main level has 10' ceiling heights and is home to an open eat-in kitchen featuring a 43" La Cornue Stove, Wolf Microwave, 72" Thermador Refrigerator & Miele wine unit. This custom gourmet kitchen has Calcutta Porcelain counters and backsplash, set around a large 6'x9' island to enjoy many gatherings. The open kitchen leads into an expansive great room with full glass exposure to 72" dual custom outdoor water / fire features on each side of sitting area. To complete the main level you will also find a dog room (built in crates & dog bath, leads out into the exterior fenced in dog run), laundry/mud room, & powder room. A custom floating staircase will lead you to the upper level which includes 2 ensuite bedrooms that lead out to their own private terrace overlooking the immaculate grounds, 2 additional bedrooms that share a bath, and a second laundry room. In the lower level (10' ceiling height) you will find a complete gym / yoga room with 4 person sauna and walkout to outdoor terrace, a home movie theater with stadium seating, office, recreation area, refreshment area, full walk in pantry, and an additional bedroom with a full bathroom. The resort style backyard features a 40' x 20' mirror gunite pool & spa, porcelain tiled patio, in-ground fire pit, outdoor shower and 200 sq ft pool house with additional bathroom. This masterpiece is fully equipped with surround sound system speakers in each room, full security system with an audio & visual package, and smart systems that seamlessly integrate with devices. Thoughtfully designed with top of the line materials, this is a unique opportunity to own a modern gem in an incredible Montauk location.

Welcome to this charming four-bedroom, three-bathroom home nestled in Hither Hills with PRIVATE Beach Access. Conveniently located only one mile from Montauk town. This spacious residence offers a perfect blend of comfort and coastal living. As you step inside, you are greeted by a spacious living area with abundant natural lighting. The kitchen boasts a large granite island, ample cabinet space, and top-of-the-line appliances. The primary bedroom suite provides a peaceful retreat with an en-suite full bathroom and walk-in closet. The remaining bedrooms are generously sized and offer natural lighting throughout. Outside, there is a beautiful wrap-around deck with Ocean views and plenty of sunlight throughout the day. This space is perfect for entertaining or enjoying the serene surroundings of Montauk. Additionally, the outdoor shower makes it easy to rinse off the sand from a long day on the private beach. With its desirable location and comfortable layout, this four-bedroom, three-bathroom house presents an ideal opportunity to embrace the Montauk lifestyle. Don't miss out on making this your new home! Turn Key for Summer 2024!

Ocean Breeze-Ditch Plains-Montauk Stylish and inviting 5 bedroom home on just under a half acre with a pool and gated entrance in the desirable Ditch Plains area of Montauk. A charming covered porch opens to the first floor delivering a double height entry foyer, an open living area with fireplace, a dining area, a country eat-in-kitchen, 2 guest bedrooms that share a bath, a powder room, a laundry room and a fabulous porch area perfect for lounging. The second floor offers a stunning primary bedroom with vaulted ceiling, an en-suite bath, and a private balcony with an outdoor shower. In addition, there are 2 additional guest bedrooms that share a bath, a lounge area and a workout room. Once outside, enjoy the lazy days of summer while lounging by your pool. The outdoor shower is available for a quick rinse after the beach and offers a door for quick access the laundry room. A rare find in a premier location. The ocean is calling!

Montauk- Ditch Plains Escape to the ultimate surfer's paradise in Montauk, the Hamptons' renowned surf Mecca. This stunning beach house offers immediate access to the world-renowned Ditch Plains beach, known for its rolling waves and endless stretches of pristine sand. As you enter the home, you feel the ocean breeze. This 2-bedroom home with a bonus loft sleeping area and lounge offers the perfect blend of comfort and style. The three renovated baths provide ample space for you and your guests to freshen up after a day of surfing or soaking up the sun. The vaulted ceiling in the open living and kitchen area adds an airy and spacious feel, while the chic decor brings a touch of sophistication to this beachy oasis. Outside, you'll find a fabulous outdoor shower to rinse off the sand and saltwater, and a private deck to enjoy an evening barbecue. This beach house is the perfect place to relax and unwind, whether you're a surfer, a beach lover, or simply seeking a peaceful retreat. Experience the beauty and tranquility of Montauk in this picture-perfect beach house. Beach house living is calling, and this is your chance to answer. Book your stay today and make memories that will last a lifetime

Welcome to 40 Fairview Ave in Montauk, a mature Tudor that combines timeless charm with the best of Montauk vintage. This classic home pays homage to Montauk's rich history, with its traditional Tudor style that harks back to the very first homes built in this beloved area. Step inside to discover a rich tapestry of classic vestiges, from the elaborate masonry chimney that greets you at the entrance to the embellished doorways and classic half-timbered style. Prepare to be wowed by the recently built Chef's kitchen, equipped with all the essentials for hosting grand dinner parties and entertaining guests. The first floor offers a spacious living area, a delightful screened-in porch, a stylish kitchen, a formal dining space, and an en suite bedroom. Upstairs, you'll find a large, light-filled en suite primary bedroom, two additional bedrooms, and a full bath. The lower level provides a walkout to the backyard, a convenient 1-car garage, and ample space for your own creative ideas. Set back on a tranquil street with a lovely elevation, this property boasts a spacious shy acre, a rarity in Montauk, with room for expansion. With a recently installed septic system allowing for six bedrooms, the possibilities are endless.

High ranch on 0.97 acre with four bedrooms, two baths, kitchen, living room, work out area, swimming pool (not heated), and wrap around upper decking. Detached one car garage, just about one mile to downtown Montauk, 1.2 miles to ocean beach, Montauk Downs State Park and everything Montauk has to offer.

Ditch Plains Coastal Retreat This is the ultimate opportunity to own two contiguous single and separate properties in the coveted surf Mecca of Ditch Plains Beach in Montauk - a dream come true for the discerning buyer. These properties, each with their own private driveway, are just a stone's throw away from the pristine ocean shore. The 5 bedroom main house embodies timeless elegance. Step through the charming, covered porch to the first floor, where you'll find a double-height entry foyer that sets the stage for the rest of this inviting traditional home. The open floorplan seamlessly combines the kitchen with a center island, stainless steel appliances, and a walk-in pantry/laundry room. The dining area flows effortlessly into a light-filled living room adorned with a wood-burning fireplace. As an extra touch of charm, you'll discover an enclosed sunroom with built-in seating and another fireplace, leading to a deck and the inviting pool area. The first floor also hosts two bedrooms that share a full bathroom, along with a powder room to cater to the main living spaces. Upstairs, the primary bedroom boasts a soaring vaulted ceiling, a spa-like bathroom with an oversized shower, dual sinks, a Jacuzzi tub, and a private deck with an outdoor shower overlooking the pool and generous grounds. Ample closet space ensures your comfort. This level also accommodates two guest bedrooms sharing a full bathroom, as well as an additional room perfect for use as an office or gym area. The unfinished basement offers an abundance of storage space or the potential to create extra finished areas to suit your needs. There is plenty of outdoor decking for your enjoyment during the warmer months. You'll find a heated gunite pool and a second outdoor shower, adding to the charm of this exceptional property. Just to the south of the main house, a picture-perfect cottage offers yet another beachside retreat. Sitting on just under half an acre, this home can be landscaped for total privacy or have an open yard to the main house to give a more estate like feel. Vibrant and chic, the two plus bedroom, three-bathroom cottage boasts 1,200 sq ft of spacious, open living areas with high ceilings. The kitchen features custom built-in seating, and the loft space offers an additional recreation area. Complete with its own laundry facilities, outdoor shower, this cottage is a gem in its own right. This is a rare and exquisite opportunity to own a turnkey compound in sought-after Ditch Plains, just moments from the ocean shore yet quietly tucked away to provide unparalleled privacy. Whether you're seeking a luxurious full-time residence or the perfect summer getaway, this is the quintessential coastal retreat you've been waiting for. Don't miss your chance to make it yours.

Welcome to your slice of heaven! Post Modern 3 Bedroom, 2 Bath, One mile to lake Montauk & white sandy beaches. Don't miss out!

Stunning beach house with views of the Atlantic Ocean and Fort Pond. Close to everything Montauk has to offer including Navy Beach, Ocean Beaches, and Montauk Village. The house is situated at a high elevation that allows for both privacy and spectacular views. Enjoy them all while grilling on the wraparound deck, relaxing in the spacious living room, or cooking a gourmet meal in the well-appointed chef's kitchen. This kitchen boasts Quartz countertops and a big center island perfect for entertaining. The centerpiece of the kitchen is a built-in wood burning oven which is made for cooking so many dishes...from big roasts to whole fish to the classic pizza. The living room has a beautiful cathedral ceiling that welcomes eastern sunlight. The backyard features a private oasis with magnificent trees and flowering plants surrounding a heated pool. This beach house has all the vibes and is a perfect blend of modern living and vintage Montauk. House can be purchased with two adjoining vacant lots to create a compound or build two more homes for $3,995,000.

This breathtaking, recently renovated 4 bedroom, 3.5 bath Montauk home has the highest of standards. With over $2million in renovations, inside and out, this home offers hardwood floors throughout, gas fireplace, high end stainless steel appliances, marble and granite countertops, formal dining room, custom foyer with open living room. The entire second level is the primary bedroom w/lofted ceilings and a luxurious En-suite w/radiant floors. Two sliders allow access to the Meranti wood private balconies and floating rooftop deck featuring priceless views of Montauk Lake. The finished basement has additional living space, a new infrared sauna and storage. The serene, private backyard offers an in-ground salt water pool, new liner & heater, new hot tub, outdoor shower and surround sound. This beautiful outdoor oasis is detailed with a stone patio and is perfect for entertaining.